PDA

View Full Version : Uncertainty about Changes to Electoral System



Investors Iraq News
11-13-2013, 01:11 PM
By Reidar Visser.
The following*article (http://gulfanalysis.wordpress.com/)* (http://gulfanalysis.wordpress.com/2013/07/26/anti-maliki-forces-in-the-iraqi-parliament-reach-another-milestone/)was published*by*Reidar Visser, an historian of Iraq educated at the University of Oxford and currently based at the*Norwegian Institute of International Affairs. It is reproduced here with the author’s permission. Any opinions expressed are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Iraq Business News.

After the Passage of Changes to the Iraqi Electoral System, Uncertainty about Their Legal StatusEver since the Iraqi parliament passed changes to the Iraqi electoral system on 4 November, doubt regarding the exact status of the action by parliament has lingered. In theory, the legal uncertainties concerning the nature of the piece of legislation passed by the government are such that parliamentary elections – now scheduled for late April 2014 – may be postponed or even canceled in a worst case scenario.
A juxtaposition of two snippets from the Iraqi parliamentary website – one on the day of the passage of the changes, and another featuring the website as it is today – highlight some of these ambiguities. On the day the law was passed, parliament published a legal text with the headline “law proposal for the revision of the electoral law no. 16 of 2005”. Conversely, today the headline for the same law simply reads, “election law for the Iraqi national assembly”.
The more recent version of the document is helpful in sorting out some contradictions that were present on the day the law was issued. In particular, it seemed strange to call the legislative act an amendment of the existing law, since article no. 47 of the newly passed piece of legislation specifically abrogated the law from 2005! But whereas semantics may be to blame in that respect, the distinction between a “law proposal” and a standard law is not so easily resolved.
That is so because over the past couple of years, the Iraqi supreme court has developed something of a pet issue regarding the exclusive right of the executive power in Iraq – the cabinet and the president – to introduce legislative projects to parliament. An independent right of parliament to initiate legislation is not recognized, and the court has consistently struck down as unconstitutional all “law proposals” that have been brought to its attention, always citing article 60 of the Iraqi constitution.
It seems clear from all accounts that the new Iraqi electoral law that was passed last week was indeed a mere “proposal”. It reportedly originated from the legal committee in parliament. As such, it has not passed through the executive power, and it would be perfectly analogous and compatible with past precedent to have the law struck down as unconstitutional by the supreme court if anyone complained.


Source: Iraq-BusinessNews.com. (http://www.iraq-businessnews.com/2013/11/13/uncertainty-about-changes-to-electoral-system/)

Post your commentary below.